Thursday, June 2. 2011The pit and the drumTrackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry
No Trackbacks
Comments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
Was any ancient Chinese city ever attacked by digging a tunnel?
What is the evidence that this drum-in-a-pit invasion alarm was anything other than an idea? Did it ever exist? Or was it merely a proposal?
It's an interesting take on hexagram 29, but it doesn't seem at all likely to me. As an interpretation it relies on the repeated kankan in the third line, which doesn't only refer to the sound of drumming.
It is an interpretation, yes. I found it interesting that some elements of the passage from the Mozi could be found in hexagram 29, and I interpreted the text in that direction. I don't know if Chinese cities were ever attacked by digging tunnels, or if this 'invasion alarm' ever existed.
All interpretations welcome. I don't think we can know anything about the Yijing save through interpretation. I interpret the kankan of the third line as the sound of a body thudding into the pitfall trap. To me this line means there's nothing you can do. But in your interpretation presumably the invading army is detected, so how do you interpret the 'do not use'? Surely if the invader is detected this would make this line a good line rather than a line of inability to do anything? So if you get it in practical divination, how would your interpretation colour its meaning in terms of addressing a situation?
In my interpretation the danger, the invading army, is approaching, and finally it enters the pit, rendering it useless. In divination it could try to tell you that when you know that danger is approaching, even when it is still far away, you should act immediately. If you wait for the danger to approach, the tools that you use to discover or avoid that danger will be useless. When the burglar alarm goes off, don't wait for the police to come but get yourself into safety. This is not the time to take risks. In other words, the 'do not use' can mean that you should not let the situation worsen if you know that the seeds of misfortune are planted. Shovel them away immediately.
If the invading army has entered the pit where the drum alarm is then I don't see how that renders the pit useless, since its only use is to tell if an invader is coming and from what direction. You'd be quite certain by that point. Also, if one were to invade a city by digging a tunnel, you presumably wouldn't want to begin digging it too far away, so the invader would surely be visible on the surface anyway. Strikes me the best defence against tunnels is a deep moat. You don't need an alarm if there is no point digging the tunnel in the first place.
|
LanguageCategorieënQuicksearchPowered by |